The Procurement Lens.
Category intelligence · Marketing · Creative agencies

Creative agencies

Brand, advertising and content agencies; production; design and digital creative.

Leverage · buyer's market as AI cuts production cost

At a glance

Global agency market

WPP Creative, Q3 2026
-5.1%
Organic; WPP group net revenue -2.1% (Q3, like for like)
OfficialWPP Q3 2026 trading update · Nov 2026
Publicis creative, Q3 2026
Low single digit
Media high single digit
OfficialAdweek · Oct 2026
Global holding groups
3
Omnicom (with IPG), Publicis, WPP
OfficialOmnicom Q3 2026 results · Nov 2026
Hours saved by AI at Publicis
200,000
Expected in 2026 (107,000 last year)
OfficialAdNews · Jul 2026
Creative agency revenue is falling at two of the three big groups as AI makes content cheaper and clients move money to media and data. Buyers have leverage: re-base production fees, move from hours to deliverables, and make agencies share AI productivity gains.

Exhibit 1Creative is the weak spot at the big agencies

Organic growth in creative/advertising, Q3 2026 (approximate)

Publicis Intelligent Creativity~+2%WPP Creative-5.1%

Publicis reports 'low single digit'; that bar is approximate. Omnicom no longer publishes growth by discipline.

Showing: Global

The category on a page

What it isBrand and campaign agencies, content production, design and digital creative.
How bigCreative is about a quarter of Publicis net revenue; media is 62%.
Market structureThree global groups (Omnicom, Publicis, WPP), plus Dentsu, Havas, Stagwell and independents.
PositioningLeverage: many capable suppliers; AI is cutting the cost of producing content.
Key riskPaying for hours and production that AI now does in minutes.
Primary leverRe-base production fees; pay per deliverable or outcome; share AI savings.

Exhibit 2Where creative agencies sit

Profit impact against supply risk, marketing subcategories

ROUTINELEVERAGEBOTTLENECKSTRATEGICCreative agenciesMediaMarket researchPrint & promotionSales enablementProfit impact →Supply risk →
JudgementThe Procurement Lens assessment

Exhibit 3Agency groups: organic growth

Q3 2026

Stagwell (net revenue)+7.4%Omnicom (core operations)+7.2%Publicis (net revenue)+5%WPP (net revenue)-2.1%
OfficialCompany Q3 2026 releases · Nov 2026

Exhibit 4India: digital takes all the growth

2026 forecast growth by medium

Digital+20.2%Print+2.5%Linear TV0%Radio-5.1%
OfficialPMAR 2026 via AdTech Today · Feb 2026

Typical savings from an agency fee review

On agency fees and production

10%25%
0%20%40%
JudgementTypical range from re-basing fees and production with AI

Value levers

In order of value.

01Re-base production with AI

Ask agencies to show where AI is used and pass on the time saved.

Publicis expects to save 200,000 hours through AI in 2026
OfficialAdNews
02Move from hours to deliverables

Price by asset or project, not by FTE. AI makes hours a poor measure of value.

WPP Creative revenue fell 5.1% like-for-like in Q3 2026
03Unbundle production from strategy

Use specialist or in-house production studios for volume content.

Agencies grow in media and data, not creative
OfficialAdweek
04Use consolidation to your advantage

With three global groups, run competitive pitches; agencies want share gains.

Publicis expects new business to add 2% to its 2027 growth
OfficialAdweek
05Own the AI tools and assets

Make sure content, models and prompts trained on your brand belong to you.

Agencies are building proprietary AI platforms
JudgementThe Procurement Lens

How to buy it

Sourcing routeLead agency for strategy; production hub or in-house studio for volume; specialists for digital.
Pricing modelFixed fee per deliverable or retainer on scope; performance bonus.
Contract termsIP and AI asset ownership, rate card, AI use disclosure, audit rights.

KPIs to track

For the monthly review

Cost per assetShare of content produced with AIAgency fee as % of working mediaCampaign effectivenessTime to market

Where most buyers are, and what good looks like

Most buyers todayBest practice
FeesFTE-based retainers→Deliverable or outcome-based
ProductionInside lead agency→Separate production hub or in-house
AIUnknown use→Disclosed, savings shared
IPAgency owns tools→Client owns assets and models
ReviewsEvery 5+ years→Annual performance review, pitch every 3 years

What AI changes

More in the AI disruption tab.

Generative AI cuts the cost of producing content variations.
Agencies' growth has shifted to media and data.
Clients bring production in-house with AI tools.

From the category playbook

Marketing & creative agencies

PositioningMedia buying - Leverage · Creative & strategy - Strategic · Production - Leverage
Recommended routeConsolidate media into a lead agency (audited, transparent); retain creative relationship; competitive production
Spec approachScope-of-work & output-based fees (not open retainers); media transparency & rebate clauses; benchmark fees
Top value levers1) Fee/retainer benchmarking 2) Media transparency & efficiency 3) Roster consolidation & production competition
Key riskMedia inflation · fee/rebate opacity · creative switching cost
Headline KPIsFee vs benchmark · media price vs index · working:non-working ratio · agency scorecard · effectiveness
What it isAgency services - creative, media planning/buying, production, data/martech - and the holding-company networks behind them.
Spend profileMedia buying dominates; creative, production, fees & martech next. Media inflation ~+4.6% globally, +9.6% in India (2026, WFA).
Market structureFour holdcos dominate (Omnicom+IPG, Publicis, WPP, Dentsu) + strong independents.
Kraljic leanMedia buying = Leverage (consolidate); creative/strategy = Strategic (relationship).
Key riskMedia price inflation, fee transparency/rebates, creative-relationship switching cost.
Primary leverFee/retainer benchmarking + media transparency (audit) + roster consolidation + output-based scopes.

Exhibit 5Kraljic positioning (category playbook)

Sub-categories by profit impact and supply risk

ROUTINELEVERAGEBOTTLENECKSTRATEGICMedia buyingCreative agencyProductionData/martechProfit impact →Supply risk →
JudgementThe Procurement Lens category tool

Exhibit 6Where the money goes

Typical cost split

60%20%12%8%
Media buyingCreative/productionAgency fees/retainersData/martech
JudgementThe Procurement Lens category tool

Exhibit 7Where the programmatic $ goes - ANA Q2 2026

% of spend

Reaches quality impressions45.1%Waste (non-viewable, MFA…)27.7%Fees / transaction costs27.2%
OfficialCategory tool benchmark

Savings potential (category playbook)

Typical range on addressable spend

8%20%
0%20%40%
T4Category tool estimate

Verified benchmarks - Global

  • Global ad spend +11.9% to $1.34tn in 2026, moderating to +8.4% in 2027; digital media price inflation running ~9-13% depending on channel
    T2WARC / WFA · Oct 2026
  • Only 45.1% of programmatic spend reaches quality impressions (ANA Q2'26) - a record, but fees still take 27.2%; the leakage dwarfs the rate
  • India media inflation +9.6% - highest of the major markets (vs +4.6% global, +3.9% US)
T1 Official statisticsT2 Industry index / surveyT3 Analyst / consultingT4 AI estimate

Supplier landscape - Global

Top global players and the local or regional players that matter here. Illustrative, from public sources; not an endorsement.

Global players

Holding companies & networks

Value levers (category playbook)

Marketing spend is mostly media - so the money is in media transparency and the working-vs-non-working ratio, not the creative retainer everyone fights over.

1Media transparency & audit

Demand full media transparency (no undisclosed rebates or principal-media arbitrage), audit the media agency, and separate media buying from creative; opacity is where the margin hides.

Media ~60% of marketing spend
2Working vs non-working ratio

Measure and shift spend from fees/production (non-working) into actual media (working); a poor ratio means you're paying people more than audiences.

Push the working-media ratio up each cycle
3Retainer → output fees

Move creative agencies off fat retainers to project or output-based fees with scope control; retainers drift into paying for idle capacity.

Scoped project/output fees, not open retainers
4Roster consolidation + decoupling

Consolidate the agency roster and decouple production from creative so you're not paying agency mark-up on production you could source direct.

Decouple production; cut roster to core
5In-housing decision

Decide what to in-house (always-on content, performance media) vs keep with agencies (brand, big ideas); in-housing commodity work is a structural saving.

In-house always-on; agency for brand

Make AI do the work

Generative AI is collapsing production cost - so renegotiate: production and always-on content that used to justify agency hours now cost a fraction. Claw that back in the fee model and require agencies to disclose where they use AI, so you're not paying human rates for machine output. The brand and strategy work still earns its fee; the production line no longer does.

Reactive vs proactive (category playbook)

ReactiveProactive
PricingFixed annual retainer→Output/SOW with tight scope control
RosterMany agencies, overlap→Rationalised roster + lead agency
TransparencyTrust the agency's numbers→Fee & utilisation transparency; decoupled production
DataAgency owns data & trading→In-house the data / trading desk
MeasurementDeliverables counted→Fee tied to business outcomes

How AI is changing the category

  • Gen-AI reshapes creative and production - faster, cheaper asset generation undercuts the hourly-fee base.
  • AI media buying, optimisation and programmatic shift value toward data and algorithms.
  • AI fee-benchmarking and media-transparency tools audit agency cost, mark-ups and rebates.
  • Synthetic audiences and AI research compress testing and insight cycles.

What to do about it

  • Renegotiate scopes and fees as Gen-AI cuts production hours - capture the productivity gain, don't leave it with the agency.
  • Demand transparency on AI media tools, data ownership and rebate flows.
  • Use AI fee-benchmarking to move to output-based pricing, not FTE/retainer.
  • Insert AI-usage, IP ownership and data-governance clauses into the master services agreement.

Each number carries source, as-of date and a credibility tier (T1 official · T2 index/survey · T3 analyst · T4 estimate). Figures are WFA media-price inflation (per market), WARC ad-spend growth and ANA programmatic transparency. Agency fees/rebates are negotiated, not published - benchmark via an independent auditor. India's media inflation is the highest of the major markets, and under half of programmatic spend reaches quality impressions.

Full written analysis

Written live for Creative agencies and your region, grounded on the figures above. Public data only.

Written live for this category and region when the page opens in a browser.

Sources

Figures checked 16 Nov 2026. Tags: Official = published by the source; Derived = calculated from published figures; Judgement = The Procurement Lens view.