At a glance
Commercial insurance
Exhibit 1Insurance rates by line
Global rate change, Q3 2026
The category on a page
Exhibit 2Where financial services sit
Profit impact against supply risk, professional services
Exhibit 3Rates have fallen for nine quarters
Global composite rate change
Typical savings at a soft-market renewal
On insurance premiums
Value levers
In order of value.
New capacity and competition: get multiple quotes for property and cyber.
Broader cover, higher limits or lower deductibles while the market is soft.
Buyers are using the soft market to adjust retentions and explore captives.
Fixed broker fee instead of commission; disclose all income.
Bank fee statements and card programme rebates are often unreviewed.
How to buy it
KPIs to track
For the monthly review
Where most buyers are, and what good looks like
| Most buyers today | Best practice | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Renewals | Rolled with incumbents | → | Marketed widely |
| Broker pay | Commission, undisclosed | → | Fixed fee, full disclosure |
| Retentions | Unchanged for years | → | Reviewed with each cycle |
| Banking | Fees unreviewed | → | Annual fee analysis and benchmarking |
| Data | Spread across teams | → | Central risk and loss data |
What AI changes
More in the AI disruption tab.
From the category playbook
Financial services
| Positioning | Audit & core banking - Strategic · Insurance & payments - Leverage |
| Recommended route | Competitive broker remarketing of insurance; audit/banking relationship review on cycle; tender payment processing |
| Spec approach | Transparent broker remuneration; fee (not commission) basis where possible; programme structure & retention optimisation |
| Top value levers | 1) Exploit soft insurance market (restructure, raise limits) 2) Fee & commission transparency 3) Payments/FX competition |
| Key risk | US casualty inflation · audit-fee rises · concentration & regulatory risk |
| Headline KPIs | Premium rate vs index · total cost of risk · broker remuneration % · payment cost per txn · audit fee vs benchmark |
Exhibit 5Kraljic positioning (category playbook)
Sub-categories by profit impact and supply risk
Exhibit 6Where the money goes
Typical cost split
Exhibit 7Commercial insurance rate change - Q3 2026 by line
% YoY at renewal
Savings potential (category playbook)
Typical range on addressable spend
Verified benchmarks - Global
- Global commercial insurance -5% in Q3 2026 - the ninth straight quarterly fall; property -10%, financial & professional -3% (17th straight), cyber -4% (13th straight)T2Marsh - Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- US casualty is the lone exception at +6% (US excess casualty +13%) on litigation and loss-cost inflation; every other region and line is buyer-favourableT2Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- Early signs of stabilisation after a benign cat season - many buyers are retaining the premium saving rather than buying more coverT3Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
Supplier landscape - Global
Top global players and the local or regional players that matter here. Illustrative, from public sources; not an endorsement.
Global players
- Marsh / Aon / WTW / GallagherGlobal insurance brokers
- Allianz / AIG / Chubb / ZurichLeading commercial insurers
- Deloitte / PwC / EY / KPMGAudit & tax (Big Four)
- JPMorgan / Citi / HSBCGlobal transaction banks
Value levers (category playbook)
This is a fees-and-premium game across very different sub-markets - insurance, banking/payments, audit - so the lever is matching the tactic to the sub-category, and on insurance, timing and risk-engineering beat broker haggling.
Lower premiums by improving the risk (loss control, cleaner data to underwriters) and timing renewal to the market cycle; present a better risk, don't just shop brokers.
Unbundle and benchmark transaction, FX and interchange-plus fees; bank pricing is deliberately bundled and opaque.
Control audit fee creep and advisory scope separately; scope and hours, not the hourly rate, drive the fee.
Make broker and advisor remuneration explicit (commission vs fee) and rebate where possible; hidden commissions bias the advice.
Balance relationship banking (credit access) against concentration risk, and keep competitive tension on ancillary services.
Make AI do the work
AI's play here is data and benchmarking: feed underwriters cleaner risk data for better premiums, and use fee-analytics to catch the payment and FX leakage that's invisible at transaction volume. For audit and advisory, the same automation squeezing consulting applies - don't pay senior rates for analysis AI now does.
Reactive vs proactive (category playbook)
| Reactive | Proactive | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Insurance | Renew last year's programme | → | Remarket in the soft market; restructure limits/retentions |
| Broker | Undisclosed commission | → | Disclosed flat fee, benchmarked |
| Audit/advisory | Accept the annual uplift | → | Fixed scope + AI-efficiency pass-through |
| Banking | Single relationship bundle | → | Unbundled, competitively tendered per service |
| Risk financing | Insure everything | → | Captive / higher retentions where it pays |
How AI is changing the category
- AI risk-modelling sharpens insurance limits/retentions and total-cost-of-risk decisions.
- Payment-analytics AI finds interchange/FX leakage and optimises routing.
- AI audit/benchmarking tools test fee fairness and reconcile faster.
- Insurers' own AI underwriting is shifting pricing - transparency matters at renewal.
What to do about it
- Use AI total-cost-of-risk models to right-size cover and exploit the soft market.
- Run AI payment/FX analytics to cut interchange and routing leakage.
- Benchmark audit & advisory fees with AI SOW analysis.
- Demand transparency on brokers'/insurers' AI pricing and remuneration.
Each number carries source, as-of date and a credibility tier (T1 official · T2 index/survey · T3 analyst · T4 estimate). Insurance rate movements are Marsh's Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 (large-account skew) - nine straight quarters of falling rates, with US casualty the lone exception. Banking, audit and advisory fees are negotiated and relationship-led - benchmark separately. The soft insurance market is a buyer's window.
Full written analysis
Written live for Financial services and your region, grounded on the figures above. Public data only.
Written live for this category and region when the page opens in a browser.
Negotiation playbook
Negotiation playbook
Insurers are competing for business. Market every major line and ask for better terms as well as price.
Pick the right commercial model
| Fixed broker feeUsual best | Transparent; broker not paid more for higher premiums. |
| Broker commission | Common; disclose and cap. |
| Multi-year insurance deal | Locks rates; useful at the bottom of the cycle. |
| Captive | Self-insure predictable risks. |
Questions to ask suppliers
- Rate cut
Rates in the market have fallen; will our renewal fall at least as much as the market index?
Good answer: at least the market index change. - Broader cover
Which cover extensions can you add at no extra premium?
Good answer: extensions at no extra cost. - Multi-year
Will you lock our rate for two or three years?
Good answer: rate lock for two to three years. - Broker disclosure
Will the broker disclose all income from our placement, including commissions from insurers?
Good answer: all income disclosed. - Claims SLAs
What claims service standards will you commit to?
Good answer: service standards for claims.
Your leverage
- Loss record
- Number of insurers quoting
- Total premium placed
- Renewal timing
Watch out for
- Rate falls kept by broker margins
- US casualty increases
- Hidden bank fees
Commercial insurance - 2026 rate movements
| Component | Change / forecast | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Commercial insurance - Global | -5% | T2Marsh GIMI Q3'26 · Q3 2026 |
| Property | -10% | T2Marsh GIMI Q3'26 · Q3 2026 |
| Casualty (Global / US) | +1% / +6% | T2Marsh GIMI Q3'26 · Q3 2026 |
| Cyber / Fin. & prof. | -4% / -3% | T2Marsh GIMI Q3'26 · Q3 2026 |
Pricing models (category playbook)
Financial-services spend hides its cost in fee structures - unbundle and benchmark each line, because the soft insurance market is a buyer's window right now.
| Insurance: disclosed broker feeUsual best | Move the broker off undisclosed commission onto a flat, disclosed fee - in a falling market you keep the saving instead of funding a % of premium. |
| Audit: fixed fee + AI pass-through | Lock a fixed audit fee with tight scope and an AI-efficiency pass-through - fees are falling as firms automate (KPMG's own audit fee fell 14%). |
| Banking: unbundled per-service | Price transaction banking, FX and advisory separately and tender them - relationship bundling hides where the margin sits. |
| Advisory: outcome / success fee | Tie M&A and advisory fees to completion or outcome rather than a retainer, and keep a credible walk-away. |
Benchmarks to bring to the table - Global
- Global commercial insurance -5% in Q3 2026 - the ninth straight quarterly fall; property -10%, financial & professional -3% (17th straight), cyber -4% (13th straight)T2Marsh - Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- US casualty is the lone exception at +6% (US excess casualty +13%) on litigation and loss-cost inflation; every other region and line is buyer-favourableT2Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- Early signs of stabilisation after a benign cat season - many buyers are retaining the premium saving rather than buying more coverT3Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
AI disruption
Tailwinds for buyers
- Faster, data-driven quotes.
- AI reviews of bank and card fees.
- Better risk data lowers premiums.
- Faster, data-driven insurance quotes.
- AI broker tools speed up marketing renewals.
- AI claims handling reduces settlement times.
Headwinds for buyers
- New AI-related liability risks.
- Cyber risk from AI raises some premiums.
- Brokers keep AI efficiency gains unless fees change.
- Insurers use AI to price risk more tightly for some buyers.
- AI-driven fraud raises some lines' costs.
- Model risk in AI underwriting.
How to capture it
Use AI tools to analyse bank fees and improve risk data before renewal.
Who is changing the market
- Global Insurance Market Index shows rate changes by region and line
- Gives buyers a public benchmark for renewals
- Medical trend and analytics data used to set budgets
- Broker analytics show where claims costs come from
- Treasury software shows bank fees across all accounts
- Fee analysis supports bank tender and renegotiation
Category playbook view
Tailwinds
- Fee-analytics catch the payment, FX and interchange leakage that's invisible at transaction volume.
- Cleaner, AI-structured risk data to underwriters earns better insurance premiums.
- AI contract review speeds audit and advisory scope control.
Headwinds
- Insurers' AI underwriting prices your specific risk precisely - generic 'market' arguments lose force.
- Banks' AI-optimised, bundled pricing is harder to unpick without your own benchmarking.
- Audit and advisory firms apply the same squeeze - then bill 'AI-enabled' as a premium.
Capture it
Bring your own AI to the table - fee benchmarking and risk data - so the pricing precision cuts your way, not only theirs.
Risk radar
Risk radar
Exposure by dimension, 0-100, Global
Risk heat matrix
Impact against likelihood, category playbook; register numbers follow
- Regulatory/conduct
- Counterparty/credit
- Cyber/data breach
- Concentration
Top risk flags
- HighRegulatory & conduct compliance
- MediumCounterparty / credit exposure
- HighCyber & data security
- MediumProvider concentration
Risk register
Soft conditions persist unless a severe storm season hits.
Litigation and large jury awards.
Commission tied to premium size.
Concentration of cash in one bank.
Market pulse
What the biggest suppliers are reporting
From their latest results and investor material.
Q3 2026 index: ninth consecutive decline; buyers retaining savings.
Q3 2026. Revenue $4.1bn; commercial risk and reinsurance +7%; new business added 11 points.
Q3 2026. Revenue $2.46bn; Risk & Broking +5% organic; AI plan targets ~$350m savings.
Q2 2026 brokerage organic growth; integrating $14bn AssuredPartners deal.
Latest developments
Dated, newest first. Checked 16 Nov 2026.
Treaty growth and new business offset lower reinsurance rates.
So what: Brokers are growing while premiums fall; push for fee cuts.
Aon Q3 2026 results (Business Wire) →Adjusted margin 21.9%; AI acceleration plan under way.
So what: Ask how broker AI savings reach you.
Reinsurance News →Property -10%, casualty +1%; all regions down.
So what: Push renewals down; lock in where possible.
Marsh →Marsh sees early signs of rates stabilising.
So what: The soft market may be near its low; act now.
Marsh Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 →Marsh index skews to larger accounts.
So what: US buyers face a split market.
Insurance Journal →What this means for your next negotiation
- Insurance rates have fallen nine quarters in a row: ask for at least the market index change at renewal.
- Brokers grow 4-6% organically while premiums fall; move to fixed, disclosed broker fees.
- Use the soft market to broaden cover and lock multi-year terms before any turn.
Signals to watch next quarter
Sets the tone for 2027 primary rates.
Shows whether the decline is slowing.
A big event could end the soft market quickly.
Curated developments (category tool)
Marsh - Global Insurance Market Index →
Marsh →
Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 →
Financial Times →
Category note
Benchmarks and forecasts - Global
- Global commercial insurance -5% in Q3 2026 - the ninth straight quarterly fall; property -10%, financial & professional -3% (17th straight), cyber -4% (13th straight)T2Marsh - Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- US casualty is the lone exception at +6% (US excess casualty +13%) on litigation and loss-cost inflation; every other region and line is buyer-favourableT2Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- Early signs of stabilisation after a benign cat season - many buyers are retaining the premium saving rather than buying more coverT3Marsh GIMI Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
Sources
- Marsh Global Insurance Market Index Q3 2026 · 21 Oct 2026
- Risk & Insurance on Q3 2026 · Oct 2026
- Insurance Journal on Q2 2026 · Jul 2026
Figures checked 16 Nov 2026. Tags: Official = published by the source; Derived = calculated from published figures; Judgement = The Procurement Lens view.